Letter From The Editor - Issue 69 - June 2019

Bookmark and Share

About IGMS / Staff
Write to Us

Cosmic Channel Changer
April 2013

Star Trek

Star Trek first aired in 1966 on NBC. Plagued by a low budget and even lower ratings, it ran for three seasons and just shy of eighty episodes before it was finally cancelled. Despite its troubles, however, it has remained the object of one of the most dedicated fan communities in the world and made a mark on American culture like few other franchises have. I was honestly not expecting much from it.

Being a lifelong fan of Star Wars, I grew up with science fiction being firmly rooted in action and spectacle. What little I'd seen of Star Trek seemed boring and the more hardcore elements of its fanbase seemed weird, even by my standards. That said, when a friend recommended I give the series a go I agreed and now, having watched the original series, I find myself in the unfortunate spot of having to admit I was wrong. Star Trek is a very good show and, at its best, is easily the equal of Star Wars, if not its better.

There were some things I was right about. Star Trek can be slow and often falls on the side of the odd. I watched it on Netflix and I would oftentimes find myself rolling my eyes at the descriptions of each episode. Save for a few rare cases, the show has little in the way of a through plot, instead following an adventure-of-the-week structure filled with scenarios that can sound downright stupid when you read them aloud.

That said, the show generally does well at turning its frequent absurdity into something watchable and often intriguing. One example that sticks out in my mind is the episode "Spectre of the Gun." The episode sees the principal cast (Captain Kirk, Spock, Dr. McCoy, Scotty and Chekov) forced by angry aliens into a live-fire reenactment of the shootout at the O.K. Corral. Forced to take on the role of the side that lost the fight, they spent the episode trying to escape what looks like certain death.

On the one hand, the episode is little more than a clear attempt to pop the crew of the Enterprise into a classic western scenario. That being the case, it's still fairly clever and never strays from feeling like honest-to-goodness science fiction. It also serves as a good example of how the show uses quality writing to overcome its sometimes zany premises. The crew eventually realizes that everything they're experiencing is taking place in their heads. None of it is real and they can only be killed if they believe in the illusion. The final showdown where they let their opponents bombard them with gunfire winds up being legitimately tense, and ultimately gratifying when we see that their plan has worked.

There are countless episodes like this one where I was skeptical going in but wound up utterly committed to the story by its ends. It's one of the most skillful uses of episodic storytelling I've ever seen in a show, and I would easily place it in the same tier as series like the Twilight Zone, which also often impressed me with its "leap of faith" style of storytelling. An episode might sound weird at the outset, but giving yourself to it and following it through to its end can lead to some unexpected joys.

Like The Twilight Zone, Star Trek also uses its stories as social commentaries. While many of the Cold War issues the show explored may no longer resonate on the same level they did when Star Trek first aired, there are nonetheless no lack of poignant stories exploring issues like global war, genocide, colonialism, religion and racism among others. Perhaps the most impressive thing it does is the manner in which it establishes, from the get-go, a world where all races and nations of humanity work together in peace and as equals. The crew of the Enterprise is made of people of all skin types and it's treated as a non-issue. There is the occasional hammy speech about togetherness and cooperation, but ultimately, Star Trek's strongest message is the one it conveys through the subtlest means.

If the show can be criticized for one thing, it's the clear low budget nature of its production. Star Trek did not have a lot of money to work with and it shows. The effects and make-up look cheap and often cheesy. The monsters in the episode "Operation: Annihilate," for instance, look more like breathing fake vomit than they do alien parasites. Likewise, the reptilian Gorn that Captain Kirk fights in the famous "Arena" episode looks like he was assembled from a second rate costume store. In many cases, the show doesn't even bother with costumes, having aliens look inexplicably human. Even the infamous Klingons look like little more than regular people wearing grey uniforms.

In a way, though, I'd cite this small budget as one of the show's strengths. Without fancy and expensive effects to fall back on, Star Trek instead had to rely on its writing and the strength of its actors' performances. It's become popular to poke fun at William Shatner for over-emoting at times, but I found his and most of the other characters to be well done. Shatner's Kirk is believable as an ultra-competent leader. Leonard Nimoy's Spock exhibits a tightly held stoicism that nonetheless oozes personality, and DeForest Kelly's Dr. McCoy is wonderfully annoyed throughout the show. His banter with Spock never failed to work a chuckle out of me.

Yes, there are moments of cheese, but most of the time the actors sink into their roles like well worn shoes, making you believe wholeheartedly in their mission and the mission of the Enterprise. There is, simply put, a sincerity and genuineness to Star Trek that is infectious. It's intelligent but lacks cynicism. It gives grandiose speeches but also has quiet moments of personal revelation that stick with you. It's a science fiction show, but one built on a foundation of likable characters and human drama. Watching it, I came to understand why Trekkies have adored this show for nearly fifty years and regret that it took me so long to find out.

Read more by Stewart Shearer

Home | About IGMS
        Copyright © 2024 Hatrack River Enterprises   Web Site Hosted and Designed by WebBoulevard.com